Immediate data -> memory location. In what position to put size specifier?

[andoram]

Learning Assembly language with Nasm I've just found that when I want to put immediate data to a memory location I can specify the size with either one of the operands, or with both of them. Example:

Code: [Select]

mov [num_i], word 0x5678
mov word [num_i], 0x5678
mov word [num_i], word 0x5678
And all of them generate the same thing (viewing in GDB):

Code: [Select]

mov    WORD PTR ds:0x80490e0,0x5678
Is there any difference between these three variants? Which way is the standard?

[Rob Neff]

To ensure proper behavior at all times I personally use

Code: [Select]

mov word [num_i], 0x5678

I always specify the expected size of data when using indirect memory references.
It is a form of documentation that I've ensured I do not overwrite any additional memory.

Additionally, this works for other things as well.
For example, this generates valid code with no warning:

Code: [Select]

mov dword [num_i], eax
but this causes nasm to issue a warning:

Code: [Select]

mov word [num_i], eax

Seeing the warning message should cause you to pause and re-examine your code.

[Frank Kotler]

As Andoram observes, it generally makes no difference whether the size specifier goes with the destination or source operand. However:

Code: [Select]

; movzx byte eax, [foo] ; error!
movzx eax, byte [foo] ; okay
So you might - maybe - want to put it in the second place always... just for consistency.

I personally usually put it in the first place, just to "get it over with". I really don't think it makes any difference when it doesn't make any difference. Programmer's choice. It is good to be programmer.

Best,
Frank